Q: I have learnt that one cannot make the niyah of a nafl along with a qaza sawm but for the sawm whose days are specified (e.g. Monday, Thursday, Yawm-e-arafah, Muharram, 15 Shabaan but not that of shawwal any that's any 6 days in the month of Shawwal), one can do qaza and one would automatically get the reward of that specified day if one has intended it as the aim is to spend that day in sawm, so just like how if one spend the nights of Qadr in doing Qaza salaat, one would get the reward of spending the night in ibaadah as the aim is to fill these auspicious nights with ibaadat. Please explain with reference.
A: The virtue of the fast is only in the situation where you keep a nafl fast on the auspicious day. To compare this against performing qadhaa on any big night is incorrect, for the virtue of the auspicious night is generally secured through any form of ibaadat whether through the recitation of Qur’aan, tasbeeh, zikr etc.
فتاوى دار العلوم ديوبند (عزيز الفتاوى) 1/389, أحسن الفتاوى 4/440
Answered by: