Aqaaid

Method of verifying whether someone is a Mufti

Q: What is the proper Islamic method of verifying whether someone who publicly presents himself as a Mufti is genuinely qualified? 

Suppose a person claims to have studied the Mufti course under certain scholars or at a particular institution, but those teachers or that institution choose not to publicly confirm or deny his qualification. At the same time, some other scholars and members of the community question whether he is truly qualified or even properly trained. In such a case: 

1. Is a person’s own claim that he studied the Mufti course and was authorized normally sufficient, or does claiming the title of Mufti require independent verification? 

2. What actually establishes that someone is a Mufti: completion of an Ifta course, a formal ijazah or diploma, recognition by qualified scholars, demonstrated ability in fatwa, or a combination of these? 

3. If the institution or teachers remain silent, should anything be inferred from their silence? 

4. If scholars themselves disagree regarding the person’s qualifications, how should students and the general public proceed? 

5. Can a person’s fatwas, writings, teaching, and demonstrated knowledge be used by qualified scholars to assess whether he is actually fit to issue fatwas, even if his formal credentials are unclear? 

6. Is there a distinction between someone being an Alim and being qualified to independently issue fatwas as a Mufti? 

7. How much verification is required from an ordinary Muslim before taking religious rulings from someone? Can they rely on public reputation, or should they refrain when there are serious doubts? 

8. Finally, when does questioning or investigating someone’s scholarly credentials become impermissible backbiting or slander, and when is it a legitimate or necessary form of protecting people from taking knowledge from someone unqualified? 

I am asking for the general principles rather than a ruling on any specific individual.

Woman with no deeni qualification conducting online Islamic classes

Q: A woman with a master’s degree in psychology conducts online Islamic lessons, programmes, and individual consultations, combining psychological concepts with Islamic teachings. However, she lacks systematic Islamic training and qualified teachers, having studied primarily through YouTube lectures and books. 

She makes statements such as, “I do not have a teacher. Allah Himself teaches me the wisdom I share in my lessons,” “Ilham comes into my heart like rain,” and “I do not have a murshid; wisdom comes into my heart, and then I weigh it against the Qur’an and Sunnah.” She frequently claims to receive divine inspiration and guidance through dreams and uses her students’ dreams to support her teachings. 

One of her programme assignments is muraqabah, in which students are instructed to describe ordinary daily activities using expressions such as, “Allah made me wash the dishes and look after my children.” 

We would like to ask the following questions: 

1. What is the Islamic ruling on her conduct, teaching methods, claims of ilham, use of dreams as evidence, and attribution of ordinary actions to Allah in this manner? Is it permissible for someone without systematic Islamic training or qualified teachers to conduct Islamic programmes and offer consultations as an Islamic psychologist, combining psychology with Islamic teachings? 

2. Is it permissible for women to consult qualified male scholars regarding her teachings and practices when no suitably qualified female scholars are available? The woman objects to this, arguing that sharing materials from her women-only Telegram channel violates the amanah (trust). Are women permitted to share relevant materials with scholars for the purpose of obtaining an accurate Islamic ruling?

The Ba Alawi tareeqah

Q: The influence of the Ba’Alawi tareeqah has spread substantially, more so in Cape Town, and now too in Gauteng. 

Are they on the right manhaj? Is it permissible to attend their gatherings and listen to their talks? 

A lot has been said about some of their scholars but Habib Umar himself seems to be very pious and adhering to Sunnah.

Disposing of Bead tasbeehs and digital tasbeehs

Q: I wanted to find out regarding the bead tasbeeh and the digital finger tasbeehs.

Bead tasbeehs: If the bead tasbeeh breaks, can we reuse the beads to make bracelets and other items? 

Can we sell these items to Muslims and non-Muslims? 

The counter tasbeehs: When the counter tasbeeh stops working how can we dispose of it? 

We make a lot of Zikr on these counters and the bead tasbeehs. Should we rather bury them in the Qabarastan?

Learning deen through self-study

Q: I am a common Hanafi layperson and I follow the Hanafi madhhab. I would like to study the book Nur al-Idah by reading it myself. 

Am I permitted to read and study Nur al-Idah as a layperson and follow the rulings mentioned in it, even though I am not a scholar or student of advanced Islamic studies? 

If it is permissible, are there any precautions I should take while studying it, such as relying on a teacher or commentary to understand difficult or technical matters?

Looking at the stars and predicting the future

Q: In 2024 a marriage proposal was proposed for. My mother asked a Moulana for istikhaara. He said that don't marry your daughter here as the stars of the groom and girl doesn't align (he checked by names). The marriage will end up in divorce and they will be not good for each other. 

I didn't consider because I thought that only Allah knows the future and qadar. I performed istikhaara for few days and the process went out smooth. So I thought its Allah's sign and I married him. But it turned out to be a toxic marriage and ended up in divorce after a year only in 2026 (even I tried to reconcile to him and I didn't want the divorce but he made the issue on his own and created a fight and divorced me). Now I am confused, is it a test from Allah?

Saying "Ya Ali madad"

Q: What is the ruling upon a Muslim who says "Ya Ali madad" but he doesn't believe Ali can help him and he doesn't say it with the intention of calling upon him to help him and he just said it because he was listening to shia latmiyats because they kept popping up on his intagram reels and it got stuck in his head?