Receiving talaaq from the "second husband" while still in the first husband's nikaah
Q: A man had previously asked me to marry him in the presence of two witnesses and I said yes. This was years ago.
My husband currently went through my phone and saw a chat regarding this marriage. He asked me about it which I said it was invalid as it was not conducted with a wali. My husband said it is valid. After having checked a Muslim girl can marry herself without a Wali.
My husband promised marriage to me again if I take a talaq from the previous boy which I did and then he, my current husband will make a new nikkah.
After doing all of this, all of a sudden my husband current gave me a third talaq. Now we are in a dilemma as to whether I can make nikkah with my second husband again as his nikkah with me was not valid.